How to Judge Quality of Academic Work

The Quality of Academic Work can be diagnosed by analyzing below listed points. We can improve the maturity of the paper by improving these.

Significance: Why was this work done? Did you solve an important problem of current interest or is it an obscure or obsolete problem?

Originality/Novelty: Is your approach novel or is it tried-and-true? Did you need to develop new tools, either analytical or physical?

Completeness: Have you tested a wide range of scenarios, or is this just a simple proof-of-concept?

Correct: Is your solution technically sound or are there errors?